The Benefits of Nanny Shares: A Guide for Nannies

As a nanny, you’re not just a caregiver… You’re a trusted partner in the family’s journey, providing love, structure, and support. But what if you could expand that partnership by working with more than one family at a time? Introducing nanny shares…..
Nanny shares are a great option for nannies and families alike, offering flexibility, variety, and, often, increased compensation. However, as a nanny, there are some important factors to consider before jumping into a nanny share situation. So, let’s break down some of the benefits and challenges of nanny shares for nannies and how to make the most of this unique childcare arrangement.
What is a Nanny Share?
A nanny share occurs when two families hire the same nanny to care for their children. This can be a great option for families who want the personalized care of a nanny but need help covering the cost. The nanny takes care of multiple children at once, often from different families, at the same time. This arrangement can take place in one family’s home, or both families might alternate homes each week.
Why Should Nannies Consider Nanny Shares?
1. Increased Compensation
In a nanny share, you’re likely to receive a higher salary than you might in a single-family role. While you’ll be caring for more children, the families typically agree to share the cost of your services, which often results in a boost to your hourly rate.
It’s industry standard for each family in a nanny share to pay around two-thirds of your typical hourly rate. This means that families receive a discount, but you walk away with a higher overall rate than you would in a solo nanny position. It’s a win-win: families get exceptional care at a lower cost, and you’re fairly compensated for the extra effort of working with two different sets of parents, expectations, and household dynamics.
2. Variety & Experience
Working with children from different families means you’ll have the chance to engage with a wider variety of personalities, learning styles, and parenting approaches. This can help you grow as a professional, honing your ability to adapt to different environments while expanding your skill set. Plus, it’s a great way to keep your workday interesting and full of new experiences!
3. Building Social Skills & Lasting Relationships
Nanny shares often allow for social interaction and playtime between the children in your care, which is important for their development. For you, this means fostering a group dynamic where the children can learn social skills, problem-solving, and teamwork. It’s also a great opportunity for you to work on guiding the children through conflict resolution and cooperative play.
This built-in socialization can also be a huge plus for families who are considering preschool once their child reaches a certain age. When children can interact regularly with others in a nanny share, it can fulfill that social need and sometimes encourage families to extend the position longer than they originally planned. By supporting social development in a small, nurturing setting, you may actually help position yourself for a longer-term placement!
What to Consider Before Joining a Nanny Share
1. Communication is Key
Clear, open communication with both families is essential for a successful nanny share. Each family may have different expectations, schedules, and parenting styles, so it’s crucial to establish clear boundaries and set expectations from the start. Regular meetings with both families will help ensure that everyone stays on the same page about routines, discipline, and other important aspects of childcare.
2. Ensuring a Good Fit
Just as with any nanny role, the families you work with in a nanny share should be a good fit for you. It’s important to make sure that the parenting styles, values, and household cultures align with your approach to childcare. You’ll also want to ensure that the families are respectful of your time, and that the children’s personalities complement each other. Don’t forget to consider a working interview or trial week to get a real feel for how the dynamic plays out. This gives you a chance to see how the children interact, how the families communicate, and how you can manage the logistics of both households effectively before committing long-term.
3. Legal and Financial Considerations
Before jumping into a nanny share, make sure to clarify the financial details. How will you be paid? Will it be based on the number of hours worked? Will both families contribute equally? In terms of taxes, ensure that both families understand their responsibilities as employers. Consulting with a tax professional (like our friends at Homework Solutions) and having a written contract can help avoid any confusion or issues down the road.
But lucky for you, if you work with A Perfect Fit and get placed with a nanny share, we’ll make sure all of that is figured out for you. We make sure the families are fully aware of the financial and legal aspects and help with the written contracts, so you don’t have to stress about it. We’ll ensure everything is clear, from payment to taxes, giving you peace of mind to focus on what matters most….caring for the children!
4. Managing Conflicts
As with any job, conflicts may arise, whether it’s with the families, the children, or both. It’s important to have a plan in place for how to manage these situations. Establishing ground rules about how disagreements will be handled is essential. Be proactive about addressing any concerns as soon as they arise to avoid misunderstandings that could sour the relationship.
5. Sick Days and Vacation
Make sure to discuss what will happen if either family is out of town or if one child is sick. How will you handle these days, and what is the policy for paid time off or sick days? Having clear guidelines in place for these situations will ensure you feel valued and respected in the nanny share role.
How to Make a Nanny Share Work for You
1. Flexibility and Patience
Working with multiple families means being adaptable. Be ready to work with different home environments, schedules, and routines. Patience is key when managing multiple children, and flexibility will ensure that everyone’s needs are met, including your own!
2. Building Relationships
Take the time to build strong relationships with the families involved. Get to know each parent’s expectations and preferences, and respect their individual parenting styles. Similarly, nurturing a relationship with the children you care for fosters trust and affection. A positive connection with both the families and children is the foundation of a successful nanny share.
3. Keep Things Organized
It’s important to stay organized with multiple children and possibly two different households. Keep track of each child’s needs, schedules, and milestones. It’s also helpful to maintain a shared calendar or communication system to keep everyone informed. This level of organization will make your job much easier and will keep the families satisfied with your services.
Is a Nanny Share Right for You?
Nanny shares can be a fantastic opportunity for the right caregiver. They offer the chance to earn more, work with multiple children, and build strong relationships with multiple families. However, success in a nanny share requires excellent communication, strong organizational skills, and a flexible mindset.
If you’re open to the idea and think you’d thrive in a nanny share environment, it’s worth exploring! At A Perfect Fit Nanny Agency, we help match experienced, reliable nannies with wonderful families…some of whom are looking for a shared care arrangement. Whether you’re brand new to nanny shares or a seasoned pro, we’re here to support you every step of the way.
Even if you work outside our agency, you can still turn to us as a resource! We’re here to help you navigate your career confidently, whether answering questions about nanny shares, helping with contract guidance, or offering ongoing professional support.

Interested in exploring current nanny share opportunities or want help finding the right fit? Reach out to us. We’d love to connect you with a family that values your time, experience, and the amazing care you provide.